Carol's Corner • Columns • Newswire

Condo-Co-op Helpline: New York City Co-ops and Condos Face Headwinds

New York City cooperative and condominium buildings face four regulatory and fi nancial issues that are driving down property values and driving up costs for the shareholders and unit owners. These include: the impacts on property values of the pied-à-terre tax (PAT); the costs for compliance with Local Law 97 of 2019; increasing fuel, insurance and staff health care costs and square footage discrepancies and other issues in NYC Department of Finance property tax calculations.

For some buildings, these financial pressures may force receivership and dissolution; for others lobbying and litigation may be the answer. Either way, for many of these buildings, absent relief from the regulatory and tax pressures, there may not be a good outcome for the shareholders or unit owners.

Pied-à-Terre Tax
The PAT is openly targeted at well-off individuals with second homes in New York City. The purpose is to obtain, via PAT, revenue that has been lost by the erosion of the income tax base in the state.

Two legal cases are challenging the PAT. O’Brien v. City of New York maintains that the rollout is fl awed because, in part, the burden of claiming exemptions has been improperly placed on the homeowners. The rollout was stayed by the trial judge. The Appellate Division 2nd Department has temporarily blocked the stay, pending the appeal.

The second action, Ross v. State of New York, maintains that PAT is unconstitutional under the New York State and United States Constitutions. The core of the attack is that any tax targeted on non-residents violates the Dormant Commerce and the Privileges and Immunities Clauses of the United States Constitution. The former clause provides that individual states may not regulate interstate commerce. The latter clause provides that all citizens of the United States are entitled to the same treatment by states regardless of residency.

The argument is that a tax targeted on non-residents interferes with interstate commerce and prejudices the rights of the non-residents to equal treatment by New York State. If non-resident owners must pay this tax, they may withdraw from the market, resulting in an adverse impact on property values.

Local Law 97 – 2019
Perhaps the most oppressive cost facing cooperatives and condominiums is compliance with Local Law 97 of 2019. On its face, the law is intended to address climate change. In its application, it targets cooperative and condominium buildings, as all other classes of buildings have access to exemptions, delays and other benefits. The cooperative and condominium buildings have no such relief.

While Local Law 97-2019 has survived challenges to date, it is facing new challenges, including lobbying efforts by the residential buildings to extend deadlines, alter compliance methods and reduce fines based on fairness.

The next step may be litigation. New York City may lawfully impose regulations that make a group poorer, and even drive some owners into distress, if the regulation genuinely advances a legitimate public purpose. It cannot intentionally use regulation as a tool to financially punish a targeted class.

The current implementation of Local Law 97-2019 may be so arbitrary that the cooperative and condominium owners may prevail in litigation. The Department of Buildings is studying this issue and is expected to make recommendations soon.

Operating Costs
There is little doubt that the tariffs and Iran War, as well as certain archaic New York State statues including the Scaffold Law are driving up costs to operate cooperative and condominium buildings. The loss of the SALT deduction for state and local taxes has only enhanced the impact of these burdens. Buildings have seen insurance costs double between 2019 and 2024. All other operating costs have increased 20% in that same period. The tariff s and rising oil prices have only served to make this situation worse.

Property Tax Square Footage Discrepancies
There may be issues with the way the New York City Department of Finance computes property taxes for older buildings. Some believe that the City has over-estimated the size of 70% of older buildings.

For older cooperative and condominium buildings, your counsel should check the size of the building in the Department of Finance records and compare that to the offering plan documents and other evidence. If the Department of Finance includes cellar space or other non-taxable space in the computation or overstating the size of the building, you must file to correct the clerical error. To date, the City has refused refunds on these overcharges, some of which have been significant for many years. Buildings may need to lobby Albany for relief.

This column presents a general discussion. This column does not provide legal advice. Please consult your attorney for specific legal advice.

Carol A. Sigmond
Partner
Nossaman LLP
12 East 49th Street, 22nd Floor
New York, NY 10017
(212)931-7251